Hyundai IONIQ 5 vs. VW ID.4: Which Electric SUV is the Smart Choice for Canadians?

Hyundai IONIQ 5 vs. VW ID.4: Which Electric SUV is the Smart Choice for Canadians?

Within a growing market, the electric SUV segment in Canada has become highly competitive, offering a compelling blend of practicality, efficiency, and cutting-edge technology. The Hyundai IONIQ 5 and the Volkswagen ID.4 are two standout rivals vying for Canadian buyers’ attention. Both electric SUVs represent significant steps forward by established automakers into the mainstream EV market, each bringing a unique design philosophy, feature set, and driving experience to the table. 

The IONIQ 5, with its head-turning retro-futuristic design and ultra-fast charging capabilities built on Hyundai’s dedicated E-GMP platform, has garnered significant praise. In contrast, the Volkswagen ID.4 takes a more conventional, user-friendly approach, using VW’s worldwide MEB platform and striving for broad appeal with its comfortable ride and recognizable SUV dimensions. 

Choosing between these two excellent electric SUVs can be a challenging decision for Canadian consumers. Here’s a comprehensive comparison that aims to break down the key differences and similarities between the Hyundai IONIQ 5 and the Volkswagen ID.4 for the Canadian market, allowing Canadian buyers get a better understanding of which of these popular electric SUVs best suits their individual needs, budget, and lifestyle.

More from Carnex Blog:

Best Electric Vehicles of 2023 and 2024 in Canada

Future EVs: 11 New EVs and Hybrids Coming in 2024

Will Buying an Electric Vehicle Save You Money?

Exterior Styling, Interior Design, and Practicality

When comparing the Hyundai IONIQ 5 and Volkswagen ID.4, the visual difference is obvious and speaks much about their differing design philosophies. The Hyundai IONIQ 5 embraces a bold, retro-futuristic aesthetic inspired by the Hyundai Pony concept from the 1970s. Its sharp lines, distinctive pixelated LED lighting signatures (Parametric Pixels) front and rear, clamshell hood, flush door handles (available on higher trims), and unique C-pillar design create a vehicle that looks unlike almost anything else on Canadian roads. 

The available wheel designs, which range from aero-optimized 19-inch to striking 20-inch on higher trim levels, add to the vehicle’s distinct appearance. This design language extends to the interior, which Hyundai calls a “Living Space.” It features a flat floor thanks to the E-GMP platform, contributing to an airy and open cabin feel. The dashboard is dominated by dual 12.3-inch screens (one for infotainment, one for the driver’s cluster) housed in a single bezel, creating a clean, minimalist, and tech-forward environment. Material quality is generally good, with a focus on sustainable materials like recycled plastics and plant-based yarns, which reinforces the company’s eco-conscious approach. A standout feature on higher trims is the sliding centre console (Universal Island), which can move fore and aft by 140mm, enhancing flexibility and front-passenger interaction.

In contrast, the Volkswagen ID.4 adopts a more conservative and familiar design approach. Its exterior styling is softer, smoother, and more rounded, clearly identifying it as a contemporary SUV within the Volkswagen family lineage. While it incorporates modern EV features such as an available illuminated light bar connecting the headlights and a full-width rear light bar, its overall shape is less likely to polarize opinion than the IONIQ 5. It aims for broad appeal, resembling a conventional crossover, which might reassure buyers transitioning from gasoline-powered vehicles. Standard roof rails add to its practical SUV look. Wheel sizes typically range from 19 inches to an optional 20 inches. 

Inside, the ID.4 continues the theme of user-friendliness, albeit with a minimalist execution that relies heavily on touch controls. The dashboard features a smaller, freestanding 5.3-inch digital driver display attached to the steering column and a central touchscreen (10-inch standard, 12-inch available). While functional, the heavy reliance on touch-sensitive buttons and sliders for climate and volume controls has drawn criticism for being less intuitive than traditional physical controls, especially while driving on bumpy Canadian roads. Material quality is solid and durable, typical of Volkswagen, but perhaps feels less premium or unique compared to the IONIQ 5’s more adventurous cabin, particularly in lower trims. The overall ambiance is less airy than the IONIQ 5, feeling more enclosed and traditional.

A key difference is that the Volkswagen ID.4 does not offer a frunk, a feature some EV owners find quite useful. Manoeuvrability in tight Canadian city parking lots is generally good for both, with comparable turning circles, though the IONIQ 5’s slightly wider stance might be noticeable in very narrow spots. Both offer available 360-degree camera systems on higher trims to aid parking. 

Hyundai IONIQ 5 vs. VW ID.4: Which Electric SUV is the Smart Choice for Canadians

Powertrain Options, Range, and Charging in Canada

The Hyundai IONIQ 5 is built on the advanced Electric-Global Modular Platform (E-GMP), which supports an 800-volt electrical architecture. This is a key differentiator, enabling significantly faster DC charging speeds compared to the 400-volt systems common in many competitors, including the ID.4. 

In Canada, the IONIQ 5 is typically available with two battery options: a Standard Range 58 kWh battery exclusively paired with a rear-wheel-drive (RWD) motor producing around 168 horsepower and 258 lb-ft of torque and a long-range 77.4 kWh battery. The Long Range battery can be paired with either a single RWD motor (approximately 225 hp, 258 lb-ft) or a dual-motor all-wheel-drive (AWD) setup (approximately 320 hp, 446 lb-ft). 

The AWD models offer significantly quicker acceleration and enhanced traction, a major plus for navigating snowy Canadian winters. Official range figures from Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) vary: the Standard Range RWD is rated around 354 km. The Long Range RWD boasts the highest rating, typically around 488 km, while the Long Range AWD model is usually rated around 414 km (figures can vary slightly by model year and wheel size). It’s important for Canadian buyers to understand that these are ideal figures. Real-world range, especially during frigid Canadian winters, will be lower. Cold temperatures significantly impact battery performance, reducing range by potentially 20-40% or more depending on conditions, driving style, and use of cabin heating. Fortunately, higher IONIQ 5 trims in Canada often include a battery heater and a heat pump, which helps mitigate range loss in cold weather by more efficiently warming the cabin and conditioning the battery.

The Volkswagen ID.4 utilizes VW’s modular electric drive matrix (MEB) platform, which employs a more common 400-volt architecture. In Canada, the ID.4 is primarily offered with an 82 kWh (gross capacity, around 77 kWh usable) battery pack. Buyers can choose between a single-motor RWD configuration producing 201 horsepower and 229 lb-ft of torque or a dual-motor AWD setup that significantly boosts output to 295 horsepower and 339 lb-ft of torque. 

Similar to the IONIQ 5, the ID.4 AWD provides superior acceleration and all-weather capability essential for many Canadian drivers. NRCan range estimates for the ID.4 RWD typically land around 443 km, while the AWD version is rated closer to 410 km. Again, these figures are subject to real-world conditions, particularly Canadian winters. While the ID.4 also experiences range reduction in the cold, AWD models sold in Canada generally come equipped with features designed to help, although the specifics regarding heat pumps have varied by model year and trim, making it important for buyers to verify the features on the specific vehicle they are considering. Early model year ID.4s in Canada sometimes lacked a heat pump, making them less efficient in winter compared to competitors equipped with one. 

Performance-wise, the AWD versions of both vehicles offer brisk acceleration suitable for highway merging and confident driving. The IONIQ 5 AWD is generally the quicker of the two due to its higher power and torque figures.

Charging performance is where the IONIQ 5’s 800-volt system truly shines. When connected to a 350 kW DC fast charger (becoming more common across Canada on networks like Electrify Canada, Petro-Canada, and others), the IONIQ 5 can theoretically charge from 10% to 80% in as little as 18 minutes under optimal conditions. This is significantly faster than most competitors and a major advantage for long-distance travel. Even on more common 150 kW chargers, it charges rapidly. 

The Volkswagen ID.4’s maximum DC fast charging speed is lower, typically peaking around 135 kW initially, though updates have increased this closer to 170 kW on newer models. A 10% to 80% charge on a capable DC fast charger generally takes around 30-38 minutes for the ID.4, which is respectable but noticeably longer than the IONIQ 5. 

For Level 2 charging at home (using a 240V charger, common for overnight charging), both vehicles perform similarly. The IONIQ 5 has an 11 kW onboard charger, allowing a full charge from empty in about 6-7 hours. The ID.4 also features an 11 kW (or sometimes 11.5 kW) onboard charger, resulting in comparable Level 2 charging times of roughly 7-8 hours for a full charge, making both ideal for overnight replenishment at home. 

Another feature highlighting the IONIQ 5’s E-GMP platform is Vehicle-to-Load (V2L), available on certain trims. This allows the car’s battery to power external devices (laptops, small appliances, and even charge another EV slowly) via an adapter, a potentially useful feature for camping or during power outages in Canada. The ID.4 does not currently offer a comparable V2L feature in the Canadian market. Therefore, while both offer strong range options, the IONIQ 5 holds a distinct advantage in DC fast charging speed and offers the versatile V2L capability.

Technology, Infotainment Systems, and Driver Assistance Features

The Hyundai IONIQ 5 makes a strong visual statement with its dual 12.3-inch displays seamlessly integrated into a single panoramic panel. One screen serves as the digital instrument cluster, offering crisp graphics and customizable layouts to display driving information, navigation prompts, and driver assistance status. The adjacent 12.3-inch touchscreen is the central hub for infotainment, navigation, climate controls, and vehicle settings. The system runs Hyundai’s BlueLink connected car platform, which generally features a clean interface, logical menu structure, and responsive touch inputs. 

Standard features across most Canadian trims include wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto (though some early models or base trims might require a wired connection—verify this), Bluetooth connectivity, multiple USB ports (including USB-C), and satellite radio. Higher trims often add features like a premium Bose audio system, a wireless charging pad, and Hyundai’s Digital Key (allowing smartphone access and control). 

The system also supports Over-the-Air (OTA) updates for maps and infotainment software, helping to keep the system current. Hyundai’s driver assistance suite, marketed as SmartSense, is comprehensive. Standard features typically include Forward Collision-Avoidance Assist, Lane Keeping Assist, Lane Following Assist, Driver Attention Warning, Blind-Spot Collision-Avoidance Assist, Rear Cross-Traffic Collision-Avoidance Assist, and Smart Cruise Control with Stop & Go. 

Higher Canadian trims often gain Highway Driving Assist II (HDA II), which combines adaptive cruise control and lane centering with additional capabilities like automated lane changes (when signalled by the driver) and adjustments based on vehicles cutting in, offering a more advanced semi-autonomous driving experience on highways like the 401 or the Trans-Canada. An Augmented Reality Head-Up Display (AR HUD) is also available on top trims, projecting key information like speed, navigation turns, and warnings directly onto the windshield in the driver’s line of sight.

The Volkswagen ID.4 presents a different technological interface. Its standard setup includes a smaller, 5.3-inch “ID.Cockpit” digital driver display mounted on the steering column. While clear, it offers less customization and information density compared to the IONIQ 5’s larger cluster. The central infotainment system relies on a standard 10-inch touchscreen, with a larger 12-inch display available on higher trims or as an option. 

This system runs VW’s latest infotainment software, featuring standard wired (and sometimes wireless, depending on model year/trim) Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, Bluetooth, USB-C ports, and available navigation. While visually clean, the system’s heavy reliance on touch controls, including touch-sensitive sliders below the screen for volume and climate adjustments, has been a point of contention. These can be finicky to use accurately while driving, especially compared to physical buttons or knobs. Voice control is available to mitigate this but may not always be perfectly responsive. 

VW’s Car-Net connected services offer remote features via a smartphone app. Higher trims can include features like a premium sound system (unbranded or sometimes Harman Kardon, depending on region/year), a wireless charging pad, and the panoramic glass roof. OTA update capability is also present for improving software over time. Volkswagen’s suite of driver assistance features, known as IQ.DRIVE, is also robust. 

Standard features typically encompass Front Assist (Forward Collision Warning and Autonomous Emergency Braking with Pedestrian and Cyclist Monitoring), Active Blind Spot Monitor, Rear Traffic Alert, Lane Assist (Lane Keeping System), Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) Stop & Go, and Travel Assist. Travel Assist combines ACC and Lane Assist for semi-automated driving assistance. On some higher trims or packages, Emergency Assist (can bring the car to a stop if the driver becomes unresponsive) and Park Assist (automated parking) might be included. 

While highly capable, VW’s Travel Assist is generally considered slightly less advanced than Hyundai’s HDA II, lacking the automated lane change feature found on the top-tier IONIQ 5s. Ultimately, the technology choice involves user preference. The IONIQ 5 offers larger standard screens, a potentially more intuitive (if less minimalist) interface with more physical redundancy for some controls via the steering wheel, arguably more advanced driver assistance features on top trims (HDA II, AR HUD), and the bonus of V2L. The ID.4 provides a cleaner, more minimalist aesthetic (which some prefer) and robust standard safety features but relies more heavily on touch controls that may require an adjustment period for some users. 

Canadian Trim Levels, Pricing, and Overall Value Proposition

Navigating the trim levels and prices of electric SUVs in Canada needs careful consideration, particularly given the major influence of federal and provincial incentives. Note: Pricing and rebate information are subject to change; always consult official manufacturer websites (Hyundai Canada, VW Canada) and government resources (like Transport Canada’s iZEV program) for the most current details.

Hyundai Canada typically offers the IONIQ 5 in several trims, often starting with a ‘Preferred’ base model, potentially moving to a ‘Preferred Long Range,’ and topping out with an ‘Ultimate’ trim. The MSRPs are ranging from $54,999 to $62,999 CAD before taxes and fees. The base ‘Preferred’ model usually comes with the 58 kWh Standard Range battery and RWD, designed to fit under the initial price cap for the federal iZEV $5,000 rebate. It includes a strong set of standard features like the dual 12.3-inch screens, heated front seats, basic SmartSense safety features, and Level 2 charging capability. Moving up to the ‘Preferred Long Range’ introduces the larger 77.4 kWh battery, available in both RWD (maximizing range) and AWD (adding capability and power). 

This trim often adds features like a heat pump and battery heating system (critical for Canadian winters), potentially enhanced charging capabilities, and sometimes wireless phone charging or upgraded upholstery. These long-range models are usually priced higher but may still qualify for the federal rebate depending on the specific configuration and current program rules. 

The top-tier ‘Ultimate’ trim typically comes standard with the Long Range battery and AWD, and includes all the bells and whistles: the panoramic vision roof (fixed glass), premium Bose audio, the full HDA II suite, AR Head-Up Display, ventilated front seats, heated rear seats, V2L functionality, power-adjustable seats with memory, 20-inch wheels, and premium interior finishes. This trim often exceeds the base MSRP cap for the full federal rebate but might still qualify for provincial rebates in places like BC or Quebec, which can have higher price ceilings or different structures. 

Volkswagen Canada structures the ID.4 trims similarly, often starting with a base ‘ID.4’ or ‘ID.4 Pro’ RWD model, followed by ‘ID.4 Pro AWD,’ and potentially higher trims like ‘Pro S’ or specific packages adding more features. The MSRPs are ranging from $48,495 to $60,495 CAD before taxes and fees. The base RWD model with the 82 kWh battery is typically positioned to qualify for the $5,000 federal iZEV rebate. Standard equipment usually includes the 10-inch or 12-inch touchscreen, heated front seats and steering wheel, and basic IQ. DRIVE safety features, LED lighting, and DC fast charging capability. 

Stepping up to the ‘Pro AWD’ adds the second motor for all-wheel drive and increased power, a crucial feature for many Canadians. This trim usually maintains eligibility for the federal rebate. Further packages or higher trims (the ‘Pro S’ equivalent) add desirable features like the panoramic glass roof, premium seating materials (e.g., leatherette), upgraded interior lighting, enhanced driver assistance features (like Travel Assist 2.0 with lane change assist on newer models), a power tailgate, 20-inch wheels, and potentially the larger 12-inch infotainment screen if not standard. Similar to Hyundai, these higher-spec ID.4s might push the MSRP above the base federal rebate threshold but could still benefit from provincial incentives.

Resale value is another consideration, although both models are relatively new to the market. Historically, both Hyundai and VW hold value reasonably well in Canada. Ultimately, the best value proposition depends on individual needs and which provincial rebates apply. A buyer in Quebec might find one model significantly cheaper than a buyer in Alberta due to differing provincial incentives, even if the MSRPs are close. 

Driving Experience, Handling, and Ride Comfort on Canadian Roads

The Hyundai IONIQ 5, powered by the E-GMP platform, provides a driving experience marked by composure, refinement, and surprising agility for its size. The long wheelbase contributes to excellent high-speed stability, making it a comfortable cruiser on long stretches of Canadian highways like the QEW in Ontario or Highway 2 in Alberta. 

Ride quality is typically well-damped, absorbing most road imperfections smoothly, although models equipped with the larger 20-inch wheels can feel slightly firmer over sharp bumps compared to those with 19-inch wheels. The suspension strikes a good balance between comfort and control, preventing excessive body roll in corners. Steering is light and precise, making manoeuvring in urban environments easy, though it may lack the detailed feedback desired by driving enthusiasts. Acceleration, particularly in the AWD model with its 320 hp and instant torque, is brisk and confidence-inspiring for merging and overtaking. 

Even the RWD models offer more than adequate performance for daily driving. The regenerative braking system is highly adjustable via steering wheel paddles, allowing drivers to select varying levels of energy recovery, including a true ‘i-Pedal’ one-pedal driving mode that can bring the car to a complete stop without using the brake pedal – a feature many EV drivers appreciate for efficiency and ease in stop-and-go traffic. Cabin noise is generally well-suppressed, contributing to a serene driving environment, although some wind noise around the mirrors or tire noise on coarse pavement might be noticeable at higher speeds. Seat comfort is typically good, with supportive front seats suitable for long journeys. Visibility is decent, though the stylized C-pillar can create a blind spot, making the Blind-Spot Collision-Avoidance Assist feature particularly valuable.

The Volkswagen ID.4, leveraging the MEB platform, prioritizes comfort, ease of use, and a familiar driving feel that aims to make the transition from gasoline SUVs seamless. Its ride quality is often praised for being plush and absorbent, effectively soaking up bumps and rough pavement commonly found on Canadian roads, perhaps even more so than the IONIQ 5, especially on models with smaller wheels. The suspension is tuned for comfort, leading to a relaxed demeanour on highways and city streets. 

While comfortable, this softer tuning can result in more noticeable body lean during spirited cornering compared to the IONIQ 5. The steering is similarly light and easy, prioritizing low-effort manoeuvrability over sporty feedback. Performance from the RWD model is adequate but not particularly exciting, feeling smooth and linear. The AWD model, with its significant power boost, feels much more energetic and capable, providing the thrust needed for confident driving in all situations, including dealing with elevation changes in regions like British Columbia or the Rockies. 

The ID.4 also features adjustable regenerative braking, typically controlled through the gear selector (‘B’ mode for increased regeneration), but it generally doesn’t offer the same range of adjustment or the aggressive one-pedal driving capability found in the IONIQ 5’s i-Pedal mode. Cabin insulation is very effective, contributing to a quiet and refined ride experience, often cited as one of the ID.4’s strengths. Front seat comfort is excellent, typical of Volkswagen, with supportive seats designed for long-haul comfort. Visibility is generally good all around due to its more traditional SUV shape and relatively large windows.

To summarize, the choice often comes down to driving style preference. The IONIQ 5 feels slightly more modern, tech-forward, and composed with a hint of athleticism, particularly in AWD form, and offers a more engaging one-pedal driving experience. Both vehicles, especially in their AWD configurations, are well-suited to handle the demands of Canadian driving, including moderate snow conditions when equipped with appropriate winter tires. A test drive on familiar local roads is highly recommended to determine which driving character better suits the individual buyer.

Warranty Coverage, and Long-Term Ownership Costs in Canada

Hyundai Canada typically provides a comprehensive warranty package that includes a 5-year/100,000 km comprehensive limited warranty, a 5-year/100,000 km powertrain warranty, and, crucially for an EV, an 8-year/160,000 km warranty specifically covering the high-voltage battery and electric vehicle system components. This extensive battery warranty is in line with industry standards and addresses potential concerns about long-term battery degradation or failure. Hyundai also often includes 5 years of complimentary roadside assistance.

Volkswagen Canada offers a similarly competitive warranty for the ID.4. This usually includes a 4-year/80,000 km new vehicle limited warranty and a 5-year/100,000 km powertrain warranty. Like Hyundai, Volkswagen provides an 8-year/160,000 km warranty specifically for the high-voltage battery system. VW Canada also typically includes 4 years of roadside assistance. While Hyundai’s base vehicle and powertrain warranty periods are slightly longer, the critical battery warranty duration is identical for both manufacturers, covering the most expensive component of the EV for a substantial period.

Long-term ownership costs are where EVs typically shine compared to their gasoline counterparts, and both the IONIQ 5 and ID.4 benefit from this. The most significant savings come from fuel costs. Charging an EV at home, especially overnight during off-peak hours, is significantly cheaper than buying gasoline across most Canadian provinces, although electricity rates vary widely (e.g., Quebec has very low rates, while rates in Ontario or Alberta can be higher). Public charging costs more but is still often competitive with gasoline, especially for Level 2 charging. 

In general, EVs have cheaper maintenance costs. There are no oil changes, spark plugs, exhaust systems, or complicated transmission fluids to worry about. Routine maintenance often includes tire rotations, cabin air filter changes, brake fluid checks (though regenerative braking minimizes wear on physical brakes), and suspension and cooling system inspections. Long-term costs for EVs include battery degradation, while the 8-year/160,000 km warranty covers extreme capacity loss (usually less than 70% health). 

Battery replacement is expensive outside of warranty, although prices are likely to fall over time, and widespread failures inside the warranty period are rare. Insurance costs for EVs can sometimes be slightly higher than comparable gasoline cars due to higher repair costs for specialized components and batteries, but this varies significantly by provider and driver profile in Canada. 

Government incentives (federal and provincial) significantly reduce the upfront purchase price, further improving the long-term value proposition. Comparing the estimated electricity costs based on local rates versus gasoline prices, factoring in lower maintenance, and considering the purchase incentives provides a clearer picture of the total cost of ownership, which often favours these EVs over similarly sized gasoline SUVs in the long run

Conclusion

The Hyundai IONIQ 5 stands out with its bold, distinctive design that turns heads. Its key advantages lie in its cutting-edge 800-volt architecture, enabling class-leading DC fast charging speeds—a major plus for Canadians who undertake frequent long road trips. The E-GMP platform also results in a roomy and airy cabin, with notably remarkable rear-seat legroom, and the unique V2L capability adds a level of practical adaptability. Its available Highway Driving Assist II technology provides sophisticated driver assistance. It’s the ideal choice for individuals who value contemporary design, the fastest charging accessible, innovative technology features, and ample passenger room.

The Volkswagen ID.4, conversely, offers a more conventional and approachable package. Its strength lies in its familiar SUV styling, exceptionally comfortable and quiet ride that excels at soaking up imperfect Canadian roads, and potentially larger cargo capacity behind the rear seats. The interior prioritizes user-friendliness (despite some touch control criticisms) and offers excellent headroom. Its driving dynamics are smooth, refined, and confidence-inspiring, particularly in the capable AWD configuration. The ID.4 is likely the better fit for buyers prioritizing maximum ride comfort, cargo volume, a more traditional SUV feel, and a design that blends seamlessly into the automotive landscape.

Both the Hyundai IONIQ 5 and Volkswagen ID.4 represent excellent steps forward in electric mobility, offering compelling alternatives to gasoline SUVs and paving the way for a more sustainable automotive future in Canada. We recommend scheduling test drives for both models, ideally back-to-back, to experience their varied driving characteristics and interior environments firsthand.

More from Carnex Blog:

Electric Vehicle Storage: How To Prep Your EV For Long-Term Parking

First-Time Electric Car Driver? Here’s What You Need To Know Before Hitting the Road

Winter Driving with Electric Vehicles: How Much Range These Popular EVs Lose In The Cold

As always, Carnex can provide you with detailed information about buying and selling used electric vehicles in Ontario.

Carnex is the top online EV expert in Canada for buying and selling used electric vehicles in Ontario.

Learn more about the benefits of buying from Carnex. We believe that all clients deserve to know the good and bad of what they’re buying. Because we wanted to know these when we bought cars. That’s why at Carnex.ca, we will proudly display every detail every step of the way. Browse all the best cars, automobile buying tips, auto insurance, young drivers, driving techniques, auto industry trends from Carnex Blog.