Used Electric Vehicle: Leasing vs. Buying
Buying an EV is likely an excellent decision you can make, especially given rising fuel costs. With a rise in electric vehicles and an increase in the availability of used electric vehicles, many potential buyers face a key decision: should they lease or buy a used EV? Leasing offers flexibility with lower monthly payments, while buying provides full ownership and potential savings in the long run. This guide examines both options to help readers find the right fit for their needs.
More from Carnex Blog:
Best Electric Vehicles of 2023 and 2024 in Canada
Future EVs: 11 New EVs and Hybrids Coming in 2024
Will Buying an Electric Vehicle Save You Money?
Used Electric Vehicle: Leasing vs. Buying
Leasing is a good option for those who prefer short-term flexibility with lower monthly payments, whereas purchasing is ideal for those who want full ownership and long-term cost savings. We’ll go over both alternatives in detail.
Ownership and Control
Leasing: Leasing a used EV is similar to renting. You agree to use the vehicle for a set term, usually between 24 to 48 months, with the option to return or buy it at the end of the lease period. Leasing doesn’t lead to ownership, so the vehicle must be returned or renewed at the end of the term. This option is particularly appealing for those who want to try out an EV before committing to full ownership or plan to switch to a newer model every few years as technology evolves.
Buying: When you buy a used EV, you own it outright once the loan is paid off, giving you complete control. You can keep it for as long as you want, customize it, and drive unlimited mileage without restrictions. Ownership also means building equity in the vehicle, which may have resale value depending on demand and condition. Buying a used EV provides long-term stability and cost benefits since, once paid off, you only have to pay for maintenance and insurance.
Cost and Payment
Leasing: Leasing generally involves lower monthly payments compared to financing a used electric vehicle, as you’re only covering the vehicle’s depreciation during the lease period. There may be some initial expenses, such as a security deposit, acquisition fees, and the first month’s payment. In addition, some leasing agreements include maintenance packages, which may reduce the cost of regular service. However, if you exceed the mileage restriction or cause excessive wear and tear on the vehicle, you may face additional penalties at the end of your lease.
Buying: Purchasing a used EV usually requires a larger down payment and higher monthly payments, especially if you’re financing. However, buyers often find long-term savings by eliminating monthly payments once the loan is paid off. Unlike leasing, you won’t face mileage restrictions or end-of-term fees. Some buyers prefer purchasing used EVs that are two to three years old, as these vehicles have already depreciated, making them more affordable than new ones.
Depreciation and Resale Value
Leasing: Since depreciation is included in the monthly payments, leasing minimizes the risk associated with EV depreciation. EVs, like other vehicles, depreciate rapidly in the first few years, especially as technology advances. However, this effect is more balanced in the used EV market, where depreciation rates tend to slow. If technology or range changes significantly over a few years, leasing can be a wise option since it doesn’t lock you into long-term ownership.
Buying: Buying a used EV does expose you to depreciation, but with used EVs, the most significant depreciation has often already occurred. This means you may experience a steadier resale value if you decide to sell the car later. Models with a strong reputation for longevity, such as Tesla and Chevrolet Bolt models, have performed excellently on the used EV market. However, resale values may vary depending on the condition, battery life, and demand for used EVs at the time of sale.
Mileage and Usage Limits
Leasing: Lease agreements often have mileage limitations ranging from 15,000 to 20,000 km per year. Exceeding these limits may result in additional costs, which may add up over time if you drive frequently. Leasing works well for drivers who have consistent, moderate mileage or who can comfortably stay within the set mileage range. This is especially important to consider while leasing an EV, as many EV owners benefit from driving more often due to lowered energy expenses.
Buying: Purchasing a used EV comes with no mileage restrictions, making it ideal for drivers who travel extensively. Long-distance or frequent drivers will not have to worry about mileage penalties, allowing them to use the car to its full potential. However, high mileage has an impact on the vehicle’s resale value, particularly if it impacts battery performance over time. Some EV owners purchase an extended battery warranty or battery coverage to protect their investment in case of high usage.
Maintenance and Repair Costs
Leasing: Many lease agreements include maintenance packages, covering routine service requirements like tire rotations, fluid checks, and minor repairs, helping drivers avoid unexpected maintenance costs. However, at the end of the lease, you may be liable for any wear and tear exceeding the lease terms, which could include paying for repairs or restoration to fulfill the leasing company’s return requirements.
Buying: When you buy a used electric vehicle, you are responsible for all maintenance and repairs. While EVs typically require less maintenance than gas-powered vehicles (no oil changes, fewer moving parts, and reduced brake wear due to regenerative braking), battery replacement can be expensive if unavoidable. Many manufacturers provide extended warranties on EV batteries, which might help to cover repair costs. Buyers should also budget for basic maintenance and verify the vehicle’s warranty status to determine how much coverage remains.
Flexibility and Upgrade Options
Leasing: Leasing a used EV allows you to upgrade to newer technology every few years. Given the fast advances in EV technology, leasing allows you to explore new features and longer battery ranges without the commitment of ownership. This short-term approach is great for people who prefer trying out the latest EV options as they become available. However, if you choose to end a lease early, you could face penalties, so consider your commitment to the full term.
Buying: Buying a used EV does not offer the same flexibility to upgrade, as you’re financially invested in the vehicle. However, ownership lets you keep the car as long as you’d like, which can benefit those who prefer stability over frequent changes. Moreover, if the vehicle holds resale value or demand for EVs continues to rise, selling or trading in your EV may provide an opportunity to upgrade when the time is right.
Leasing vs. Buying: the Pros and Cons
Leasing a used electric vehicle has become an appealing choice for many drivers who want to drive an electric car but do not want to pay the hefty upfront costs that come with buying new. Leasing provides flexibility, reduced monthly payments, and a short-term commitment, making it a viable option for people who wish to swap vehicles every few years or want to try out an EV before committing to a purchase. However, there are also significant trade-offs to consider, such as mileage restrictions and the absence of ownership. Here, we explore the pros and cons of leasing a used EV to help you decide if it aligns with your financial and driving needs.
Pros of Leasing a Used EV
Lower Monthly Payments
Leasing generally requires lower monthly payments than financing a car purchase, as payments cover only the vehicle’s expected depreciation during the lease term rather than the full cost of the vehicle. This allows lessees to access a quality EV model with less financial burden compared to purchasing.
For those on a tight budget, leasing a used EV makes EV driving more affordable, particularly with electric models that hold their value well over time, such as the Tesla Model 3 and Nissan Leaf.
Reduced Upfront Costs
Compared to buying, leasing usually has lower upfront costs. Lessees might pay a security deposit, an acquisition fee, and the first month’s payment instead of a large down payment. This lower initial cost makes leasing a more feasible option for drivers who want the benefits of an EV but do not want to make a large down payment.
Flexibility to Upgrade
Leasing allows you to drive a newer vehicle every few years without having to deal with the difficulties of selling or trading in your previous automobile. Given the quick developments in EV technology—such as increased battery range, faster charging, and more intelligent features—leasing is an easy way to stay updated. For those who prioritize having access to the latest EV features and want the option to upgrade quickly, leasing aligns well with this preference.
Minimal Repair Responsibilities
Many leasing agreements include maintenance packages or cover certain maintenance requirements, like tire rotations, inspections, and regular checkups, minimizing out-of-pocket expenses.
Lease terms often fall within the EV’s warranty period, ensuring that major repairs are covered, especially for critical components like the battery, which can be expensive to replace. This coverage eliminates concerns about unexpected repair costs, making leasing a low-maintenance option.
Cons of Leasing a Used EV
No Ownership or Equity
At the end of a lease, the lessee doesn’t own the vehicle and has no equity in it. Leasing doesn’t build any long-term investment, unlike buying, where the car eventually becomes an asset. If you want to keep the car after the lease term, some agreements allow for a buyout, although this normally means paying the residual value, which may be less than the market value of a similar used EV.
Mileage Restrictions
Leasing agreements typically include annual mileage limits, often between 15,000 and 20,000 km. Exceeding this mileage can lead to overage fees, which can be costly at lease end. If your driving habits change, you could face substantial penalties. For EV drivers who commute long distances or prefer taking frequent road trips, mileage limits might be restrictive. It’s essential to realistically estimate your mileage needs before committing to a lease.
Potential Wear-and-Tear Fees
Lessees are responsible for keeping the car in the condition specified by the lease provider. Excess wear-and-tear penalties may occur at the lease’s end if there is considerable damage, dents, or scratches that go beyond normal use.
Some leasing companies charge high fees for any cosmetic or structural issues, which may not seem excessive to the driver but can be considered “damage” by the leasing company. As such, leasing may not be ideal for those with unpredictable driving environments or those who prioritize personalization or customization.
No Long-Term Cost Savings
While leasing typically has lower monthly payments, it can become costly in the long run if you lease consecutively. With each new lease, you face ongoing payments without building ownership or residual value. Over time, buying a used EV and owning it long-term usually leads to more cost savings since, after the loan is paid off, the only expenses are maintenance and insurance.
Less Flexibility with Early Termination
Breaking a lease early can lead to substantial penalties, making it more rigid than owning, where you have the freedom to sell or trade in your vehicle at any time. Most leasing agreements require paying early termination fees or the remaining payments in case of early exit, which can be financially prohibitive.
This lack of flexibility may not suit drivers whose lifestyles, job locations, or financial situations may change significantly over a few years.
Potential Limits on Customization
Since leased vehicles must be returned in good condition, lessees are generally restricted from making permanent modifications or customizations to the car. For those who want to personalize their EV, such as upgrading software or modifying hardware components, leasing may not be suitable.
Some leasing companies impose penalties for any modification, so if customization is a priority, owning the vehicle outright may be a better choice.
Benefits of Buying a Used Electric Vehicle
Affordability and Lower Depreciation
One of the most significant advantages of buying a used EV is the lower purchase price compared to new models. New EVs can depreciate rapidly in the first few years, often losing 20–30% of their value, similar to other new cars. By buying used, you avoid the steepest depreciation, allowing you to own a quality electric vehicle at a fraction of the original price.
Because EVs generally have fewer moving parts than gasoline cars, well-maintained used EVs can offer great value with fewer maintenance concerns. This reduced depreciation cost is especially appealing for buyers who want to maximize their investment without sacrificing vehicle quality.
Ownership and Customization Freedom
Unlike leasing, buying a used EV gives you complete control over the car. Ownership means no mileage restrictions, wear-and-tear limitations, or lease-end fees, making it ideal for drivers who want full freedom and flexibility in using their car.
Owning your EV lets you personalize it, whether it’s by upgrading the interior, enhancing tech features, or even modifying the exterior appearance. This freedom appeals to drivers who see their car as an extension of their style and prefer the option to customize.
Lower Long-Term Costs and Potential Savings
Once you’ve paid off the used EV or completed financing, you can enjoy driving without a monthly payment. Unlike leasing, where payments are perpetual if you renew, owning means you’ll eventually eliminate this regular expense. Long-term ownership is particularly cost-effective for those who plan to keep the car for several years.
Potential Resale Value Stability
As more consumers look to adopt sustainable vehicles, the demand for used EVs has grown, helping to stabilize and even increase the resale value of popular models. Some brands are known for their high-quality batteries that retain capacity over time, which can positively affect resale value. Tesla, for example, has shown strong demand in the used market, with some models retaining a high resale value.
EVs with solid reputations for range, battery life, and low maintenance are more likely to retain value, making them appealing for resale.
Which is the Right Choice for You?
Leasing is often more cost-effective in the short term, especially if you value lower monthly payments, short-term flexibility, and the ability to switch to a new EV model every few years. It’s also attractive for drivers who want access to reduced charging rates without the responsibility of long-term ownership.
Buying, on the other hand, is the most economical option for those looking to commit to an EV for a longer period. Ownership also means fewer restrictions, freedom to customize, and the potential for long-term savings as the car’s value stabilizes.
Ultimately, understanding the costs and benefits of leasing vs. buying in Canada enables you to make an informed decision that is consistent with your financial goals and commitment for sustainable driving.
As always, Carnex can provide you with detailed information about buying and selling used electric vehicles in Ontario.
Carnex is the top online EV expert in Canada for buying and selling used electric vehicles in Ontario.
Checking out the best selling electric vehicles from Carnex inventory today!
Learn more about the benefits of buying from Carnex. We believe that all clients deserve to know the good and bad of what they’re buying. Because we wanted to know these when we bought cars. That’s why at Carnex.ca, we will proudly display every detail every step of the way. Browse all the best cars, automobile buying tips, auto insurance, young drivers, driving techniques, auto industry trends from Carnex Blog.