Make the right choice between a used luxury car or a new economy car

by Sep 29, 2021Car buying, New Cars, Old Cars0 comments

Selling your car has never been easier.

Get on average $500 more than anywhere else.

Buying a used luxury vehicle to make your dream car now might be something you can afford. Especially when you can buy a used luxury vehicle for the same price as, or even less than a new economy car. Taking that into consideration, here comes a big question: How to make the right choice between a used luxury car or a new economy car?

used luxury car or new economy car

Here we will tackle used luxury cars vs new economy cars in this blog! It can help you to make the right choice for your lifestyle!

Pros & Cons for used luxury car

Pros:

A premium experience

Most luxury vehicles come equipped with premium materials like leather seats, walnut wood trim, soft-touch plastics and aluminum inserts. The design is the easiest way to distinguish between luxury vs economy vehicles, as luxury design tends to be bolder and more premium looking to make it seem like you paid more than you really did.

Superior performance

Luxury vehicles are engineered to drive smoother and quieter than economy models.

A late-model used luxury vehicle could accelerate, steer and brake better than a new economy vehicle at the same price point. Luxury vehicles make less noise when you are on the road, which also enhances your overall enjoyment of driving.

Depreciation

Luxury cars usually depreciate less in value than economy vehicles in general. When you buy a used luxury car, the big depreciation hit has already been taken by the first owner. Therefore, the value of the vehicle won’t continue to plummet on a used luxury car.

Cons:

Less fuel efficient

An exhilarating drive doesn’t always mean higher gas prices, but most luxury vehicles come with more powerful engines that are less fuel-efficient compared to economy vehicles. In addition, many luxury car engines require premium fuel that adds to the cost of fuel.

More expensive maintenances and repairs

Because the cost of the parts is higher, repairs and maintenance can be more costly on luxury vehicles. Furthermore, some luxury vehicles can only be repaired by certified mechanics who are familiar with the brand. That’s another factor that raises the cost of repairs.

Used luxury vehicles that have high mileage are often more complex, since they will usually need more maintenance than new cars.

Shorter warranty

If you bought a used luxury vehicle, you may not be covered by the new-car warranty. You may purchase an extended warranty to give you the coverage but that’s an added cost to the ownership.

Higher insurance cost

Since luxury vehicles come at a steeper price, the insurance cost on a luxury vehicle outweighs that of non-luxury cars is not a surprise. Other factors such as your driving history, address, and the insurance company can also cause different results on your insurance payments.

Pros & Cons for economy car

Pros:

More fuel efficient

Although luxury cars are not always having a higher gas consumption and cost. However, fuel economy will most likely be better on many economy cars.

Longer warranty

It depends on the manufacturer, for new vehicles a typical auto warranty coverage is at least a three-year limited warranty/50,000 km – meaning a warranty that covers needed repairs in the first three years you own the car, or for the first 50,000 km you drive it, whichever comes first.

Better selection

It could be easier to find a new car that’s right for you. Since you can go to any franchise dealership and shop around for the new vehicle that fits your needs. While used vehicles are sold by dealerships or owners, and have a greater degree of variation on mileage and condition level.

Less maintenances and repairs

A new vehicle in perfect condition will only have a few miles on it. Therefore, a new car should only need oil changes and tire rotations as regular maintenance. Any repairs within the warranty period are also covered under the new-car warranty.

Cons:

Steeper depreciation

As the first owner of a new car, you will be hit by the highest depreciation in value in the first few years. In general, the residual and resale value of economy cars are most likely to be lower compared to luxury cars

Less premium tech features

While many luxury automakers include premium tech features in their standard package, only high-end model economy cars will come with similar features. Therefore, if tech features are what you’re looking for, instead of only looking for a high-end economy model, it may be worth it to take a look at its luxury competitors.

A brand-new economy car will get you where you need to go, but it will look less upscale to a luxury car. There are positives and negatives to owning a used luxury vehicle or a brand-new economy car. Paying extras to enjoy some luxury features or making a practical choice, it all depends on your needs.

Visiting Carnex website, you will have a large selection of luxury or economy cars. No matter what’s at your choice, we can help you to find the perfect vehicle for you at an affordable price!

Learn more about the benefits of buying from Carnex. We believe that all clients deserve to know the good and bad of what they’re buying. Because we wanted to know these when we bought cars. That’s why at Carnex.ca, we will proudly display every detail every step of the way. Browse all the best cars, automobile buying tips, auto insurance, young drivers, driving techniques, auto industry trends from Carnex Blog.

Want to Trade-In Or Sell Your Used Car?

Get a free online trade in appraisal in minutes without having to come to the dealership. Get cash or trade it in for any car on our lot. Our offer average $500 more than anywhere else

Why a Used Tesla Model 3 or Model Y Is Often a Smarter Choice Than Buying New in Canada

In January 2026, with Tesla launching new trims like the Model Y Standard in Canada, more drivers are comparing new Tesla vehicles to used...

Tesla Prepares Upgraded Exterior Cameras as New “IMX00N” Code Appears in Firmware 

In November 2025, Tesla appears to be preparing another significant hardware upgrade, this time involving its exterior cameras. A newly discovered...

Tesla Model Y Performance Now Supports Vehicle-to-Load (V2L): What It Means for EV Buyers in Canada

When shopping for a used Tesla in Canada, many buyers look at range, Tesla battery life, and resale value. Now there’s another major factor to...

A Guide to Buying a Used Car in Canada

Buying used car can be a great way to get on the road and cut some numbers off the price tag of the car that you want. In addition, it will save you...

How to Choose the Right Used Electric Vehicle: Here are 7 Simple Steps To Follow

How to Choose the Right Used Electric Vehicle: Here are 7 Simple Steps To Follow For more than a decade, the market for automobiles has seen an...

How to Get the Best Value for Your Used Tesla in Canada: Tesla Trade-In vs. Third-Party Offers

How to Get the Best Value for Your Used Tesla in Canada: Tesla Trade-In vs. Third-Party Offers If you own a used Tesla in Canada and are considering...

Best cars for driving through Canadian winters

No matter where you live in Canada, Canadian drivers all have one thing in common: our snowy and icy winter roads. Canadian drivers tend to look for...

Tesla Lowers Financing and Lease Rates for Model Y in Canada — Great News for Tesla Buyers and Used Tesla Shoppers

On October 24 2025, Tesla Canada has quietly launched new, lower financing and lease rates for the popular Model Y, just days after introducing...

Electric Vehicle Rebates for Canadians: How to Save Money When Buying A EV in Canada

Electric Vehicle Rebates for Canadians: How to Save Money When Buying A EV in Canada With climate change and increasing gasoline prices dominating...

Who is Carnex?

Carnex is an EV dealer built for Canadians to buy and sell electric vehicles. Our mission is to provide Canadians with an alternative and transparent way to buy and sell used electric vehicles and to accelerate the transition to a sustainable green future.

Carnex is the leading EV Dealership in Ontario, with the company’s headquarters located in Toronto, Ontario.
Carnex is the fastest and cheapest way to buy an EV. We collect your old car without extra charges. Buy Now-Pay Later Financing is available.

Why buy from Carnex?

Carnex is trusted by over 18 million buyers to find amazing discounts on used EVs and new EVs in their neighbourhood. Carnex specializes in electric vehicles, and we make the effort to make sure your EV purchase from us will be worry-free. Our skilled EV technicians perform a comprehensive diagnostic on all of our electric vehicles at Carnex because your satisfaction is very important to us. Carnex.ca will help you find the best EV bargains among the listings across Canada, and we’ll provide you with the vehicle history and comprehensive reviews for each EV.

Why Choose Us

We choose to only sale quality and zero-accident used vehicles. We are so confident in our cars that we will shamelessly show you all the perfections and imperfections of the vehicle – from the Chasis pictures to chipped paint spots.

We also offer a 10-day no question asked return policy and an 100-day in house mechanical warranty to make your purchase risk-free.

Get In Touch

6 + 2 =