Are Gas or Electric Vehicles a Better Deal?

Are Gas or Electric Vehicles a Better Deal?

The debate between gas and electric vehicles has significantly increased in recent years, as consumers seek more sustainable and cost-effective transportation options. While traditional gasoline vehicles have dominated the market for decades, the rise of electric vehicles presents a compelling alternative.

However, will electric vehicles be a better deal in the long run? When considering the purchase of a new vehicle, it’s essential to evaluate not only the upfront costs but also the long-term financial implications. While electric vehicles have a greater starting cost than their gasoline counterparts, calculating the total cost of ownership over the vehicle’s lifetime might reveal significant savings. Maintenance, fuel expenses, and available incentives are all important considerations when establishing the true economic value of electric vehicles. Let us work out the details of this.

More from Carnex Blog:

Best Electric Vehicles of 2023 and 2024 in Canada

Future EVs: 11 New EVs and Hybrids Coming in 2024

Will Buying an Electric Vehicle Save You Money?

As always, Carnex can provide you with detailed information about buying and selling used electric vehicles in Canada.

Carnex is the top online EV expert in Canada for buying and selling used electric vehicles in Canada.

Are Gas or Electric Vehicles a Better Deal?

Initial Cost Comparison: Electric Vehicles vs. Gasoline-Powered Cars

One of the most significant issues for buyers is the initial cost comparison between electric and gas-powered vehicles. While electric vehicles are normally more expensive, technological innovation and competition have resulted in cheaper options in recent years. 

According to data from Cox Automotive, the average price for a new EV has dropped significantly—by $14,300 in 2023 compared to the previous year. This equated to just $2,800 more than the average price for a new gas-powered vehicle. With the EV industry expanding rapidly, the price margin is projected to narrow further in the future years as manufacturers develop more affordable models and enhance battery technology, which is the most expensive part of an EV.

You can also reduce the cost of an EV by taking advantage of government rebates in Canada, which can save you thousands of dollars. For example, federal incentives for electric vehicles offer up to $5,000 for purchasing or leasing an EV, and provincial incentives are also available to help offset the initial cost and make EV ownership more financially appealing.

On the other hand, it is important to balance this initial cost with the possible long-term savings associated with electric vehicle ownership. Electric vehicles provide substantial long-term financial benefits. Lower maintenance and repair costs, as well as reduced fuel use, all contribute to potential savings during the vehicle’s lifetime. 

Factors Influencing the Cost of EV Ownership

Costs of Maintenance and Repair

Electric vehicles typically have fewer moving parts than conventional gas vehicles, which means lower maintenance and repair expenses. EVs also have the typical function of “regenerative” braking, which recovers energy usually wasted while braking and saves on braking pad replacements. With fewer components subject to wear and tear, EV owners can anticipate lower servicing costs over time, which contributes to overall cost savings.

Costs of Electricity vs. Gasoline

One of the major advantages of electric vehicles is that they are cheaper to operate than gasoline-powered vehicles. Electricity is often cheaper per kilometer than gasoline, leading to significant fuel savings for EV owners. For example, in areas of Canada with low energy pricing, such as Ontario or Quebec, buying an EV can result in significantly lower operating expenses than a gasoline vehicle. Furthermore, public charging infrastructure and home charging options make electric vehicle ownership more convenient and affordable.

Costs of Insurance

Insuring your vehicle is an important aspect of ownership that protects you and your passengers. The procedure for EV insurance is the same as it would be for conventional vehicle coverage. It provides collision, bodily injury, liability, and comprehensive coverage. As with any vehicle, the exact price will depend on several factors. However, insurance for an EV is often more expensive than standard gas-powered vehicles. A particular reason is the cost of automobile parts; for example, the replacement of a battery pack, which might cost more than $20,000.

Incentives for EV Purchases

The Canadian government provides EV incentives to encourage consumers and businesses to purchase electric vehicles. These incentives aim to minimize the cost of electric vehicles while promoting the use of sustainable forms of transportation. Canada’s provincial governments are also offering a variety of incentives to boost the adoption of electric vehicles, these rebates are helping in lowering the cost of electric vehicles for both consumers and businesses.

Pros & Cons of Electric Vehicles

EVs can deliver more sustainable and cost-effective travel in the long run, but they are not without drawbacks:

Pros of EVs

Zero Emissions: EVs have zero emissions, which is one of its main benefits. Electric vehicles are environmentally friendly forms of transportation. As a result, they are a wonderful alternative for anyone trying to lower their carbon footprint and benefit the environment. Furthermore, EVs not only eliminate all dangerous emissions from engines, but they are also more silent, which most drivers enjoy.

Lower Fuel Costs: Gas-powered cars need more maintenance than electric vehicles. While acquiring an electric vehicle may appear more pricey at first, filling up at a petrol station is substantially more expensive than charging. An electric car typically costs half the price of fuel as a gas-powered vehicle. This leads to huge savings over time. This is especially true in low-cost energy areas, such as Ontario and Quebec, where charging your EV costs less than filling up your gas car.

Low Maintenance Cost: Electric vehicles require less maintenance than gas-powered autos. Electric motors have fewer moving parts than gas engines, which explains the reason. As a result, fewer components need to be maintained or replaced. Additionally, electric vehicles do not require oil changes, which saves both time and money. Furthermore, many of the features available on an EV, such as regenerative braking, significantly help the EV retain a good driving condition for a longer period.

Better Driving Experience: Compared to gas-powered vehicles, electric vehicles offer a more comfortable driving experience. This is because electric motors accelerate more smoothly and fast due to their tremendous instantaneous torque and low level of noise. It can also be a more comfortable and relaxing ride without the noise and vibrations associated with a gasoline engine. This also means that EVs emit no noticeable noise when driving, providing a significantly improved driving experience.

Regenerative Braking: Regenerative braking systems in electric vehicles convert energy wasted while braking into useful energy. This is an excellent feature for boosting the range of an electric vehicle. Furthermore, because the brakes get used less frequently, they can last longer. This extends the driving range of your electric vehicles while also keeping other vehicle components in good condition over time.

Cons of EVs

Limited Range: The majority of current electric vehicles have a range of at least 160 kilometers per charge. This may be good for short trips, but not for longer ones. Weather, driving habits, and geography, on the other hand, can all influence an electric vehicle’s range. Furthermore, getting additional range for an EV is typically expensive and may not be the most cost-effective option when compared to purchasing a typical ICE vehicle.

Long Charging Time: Charging an electric vehicle takes longer than filling a gasoline tank. Charging an electric vehicle can take anywhere from a few hours to a whole day, depending on the charger used and the size of the battery. This can be quite an issue for people who have to drive long distances or don’t have access to charging stations.

High Initial Costs: Despite becoming more affordable, gas-powered cars remain less expensive than electric vehicles. This may discourage many people from acquiring an electric vehicle. Additionally, owners have to set aside money for future battery replacement costs, which may be significant if they choose to use an EV for an extended period. 

Charging Infrastructure: In some areas of Canada, there is still not sufficient infrastructure to accommodate electric vehicle charging. As a result, some EV owners may have difficulty finding a charging station, particularly in remote regions. Furthermore, some drivers may be concerned about the range anxiety that comes from not knowing where the next charging station is.

Is an Electric Vehicle Right For You?

Determining whether the next set of vehicles should be electric should be considered in the same way that deciding which model or design of a regular car is best for you: focus on your lifestyle and needs. If your commute is comfortable with the available range of an EV, or if you like its stylish appearance and environmental benefits, an EV may be an excellent choice. 

Consider these key aspects when purchasing to ensure that an EV is a worthwhile investment.

Your Driving Style: EVs operate differently than you may expect. It must be considered that you think about your lifestyle in terms of both form and function. Because it relies on regenerative braking, you should expect slower braking but a smoother overall ride.

EV range: If you have a long commute to work and don’t have access to charging stations along the way or at your destination, think about the vehicle range of your potential new vehicle. The average battery range varies significantly depending on the model. Make sure you don’t get an EV that you can’t easily keep charged for your everyday commute.

Access to chargers: Before visiting a dealership for a purchase, check for charger availability in your neighborhood or consider the expense of installing and maintaining an at-home charger. This involves evaluating the level one, two, and three options against your driving requirements.

Electric vehicles provide significant financial and environmental benefits to drivers. Despite higher initial costs, the long-term savings associated with lower maintenance and fuelling expenses, as well as financial incentives make electric vehicles an affordable transportation option. However, you have to determine which elements are most important to you and whether an electric vehicle works for your overall lifestyle.

Before purchasing a full EV, you should carefully estimate the total cost of owning an electric vehicle. By taking into account the expenses listed above, such as the purchase price, fuelling costs, maintenance, and any applicable incentives. It will provide you with valuable insights into the financial implications of electric car ownership and allow you to make smarter decisions.

More from Carnex Blog:

EV Charging Security: Is Your Electric Vehicle Charger Safe?

11 Tips for Driving an EV in Canadian Winter

The 11 Best Car Apps and Tools For Car Buyers in Canada

As always, Carnex can provide you with detailed information about buying and selling used electric vehicles in Canada.

Carnex is the top online EV expert in Canada for buying and selling used electric vehicles in Canada.

Learn more about the benefits of buying from Carnex. We believe that all clients deserve to know the good and bad of what they’re buying. Because we wanted to know these when we bought cars. That’s why at Carnex.ca, we will proudly display every detail every step of the way. Browse all the best cars, automobile buying tips, auto insurance, young drivers, driving techniques, auto industry trends from Carnex Blog.